New York Giants fans are growing increasingly frustrated with General Manager Joe Schoen. Many are calling for his firing due to a series of controversial decisions that have left the team struggling this season.
Joe Schoen, the current general manager of the New York Giants, is under intense scrutiny as the team’s performance continues to fall short of expectations.
Fans are increasingly calling for Schoen’s dismissal, frustrated with the team’s ongoing struggles during the 2024 NFL season.
The recent 30-7 loss to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers has intensified these demands, with many supporters questioning the decisions that have defined Schoen’s tenure.
One Twitter user, @MrBaddog7676, expressed frustration, tweeting,
“I was on board with keeping Schoen & Daboll next season, but after that disgraceful effort today, I’m calling an audible. FIRE THEM ALL!”
Via: X
User @AFanWithAMic agreed, tweeting,
“I’m with ya! It had to be something VERY bad for me to WANT to fire them. 6 games left and here we are. They gotta go!”
Via: X
Joe Schoen’s Controversial Roster Decisions Have Led To Significant Fan Dissatisfaction
Schoen, who became the Giants’ general manager in January 2022, was initially seen as a promising choice to lead the franchise back to success.
He introduced modern scouting methods and brought a fresh approach to the team’s operations. Additionally, he invested in promising draft picks like Kayvon Thibodeaux, Evan Neal, and Deonte Banks.
However, his handling of critical roster decisions has led to a growing chorus of dissatisfaction.
The decision to offer quarterback Daniel Jones a four-year, $160 million contract in 2022 has become a central point of criticism.
The Giants released Jones in 2024 after he failed to meet expectations, leading fans to question the wisdom of the initial investment.
Additionally, Schoen’s decision to let fan-favorite running back Saquon Barkley sign with the rival Philadelphia Eagles as a free agent has only added to the discontent.
One frustrated fan tweeted,
“Schoen has to go. Keeping DJ over Saquon was all I needed to see. They could have signed both. But Schoen had to have it his way or the highway. Can’t be a GM that way.”
Via: X
Many view this move as a significant loss for the franchise, which casts doubt on Schoen’s ability to manage key players effectively. The dissatisfaction has not been limited to fans.
Rookie wide receiver Malik Nabers recently made headlines by publicly criticizing the coaching staff. He even hinted that the team’s problems extend beyond the quarterback position.
#Giants WR Malik Nabers: "It ain't the quarterback. Same outcome when we had DJ (Daniel Jones) at quarterback. It ain't the quarterback."
— Ari Meirov (@MySportsUpdate) November 24, 2024
Reporters: "What is it? Is it the play-calling?"
Nabers: "I don't know."
(🎥 @charlottecrrll)pic.twitter.com/LIVRnaWM8n
This tension suggests a deeper divide within the locker room. Furthermore, it complicated Schoen’s efforts to establish a cohesive and competitive team.
Despite these criticisms, some argue that Schoen inherited a challenging situation and should be given more time to implement his strategy.
Some fans are still hopeful, saying,
“It’s tough, but I want to keep Schoen and Daboll. I believe there’s promise, and the team has improved, even if the results are painful.”
Via: reddit
They point out that he has modernized the Giants’ approach to scouting and brought in fresh talent. However, the results have yet to translate into consistent success on the field.
New York Giants Co-Owner John Mara Expressed His Intention To Retain Joe Schoen and Brian Daboll For The 2025 Season
As the Giants navigate a turbulent 2024 season, the pressure on Joe Schoen and head coach Brian Daboll is reaching a breaking point.
The team’s ownership, led by John Mara, faces a crucial decision: stay the course with Schoen or respond to fan demands for a leadership change.
The New York Giants plan to retain GM Joe Schoen and head coach Brian Daboll for 2025 despite a tough 2024 season.
Let me squash the corny debate happening on twitter every Eagles game.
— Lawrence Tynes (@lt4kicks) November 25, 2024
Unless the Giants signed the Eagles entire OL, Two Pro Bowl WR’s, and Pro Bowl TE this is not the same thing. Saquon is not producing like this in NY with their current roster.
Debate whether they signed…
The team, currently at 2-8, has struggled since a fallout between Daboll and former defensive coordinator Wink Martindale.
The departure of star running back Saquon Barkley to the Eagles, which aired on “Hard Knocks,” has also contributed to their difficulties.
Despite widespread criticism and media mockery, co-owner John Mara, who has closely followed the team’s decisions, expressed confidence in Schoen back in October and appears committed to continuity.
According to CBS Sports’ Jonathan Jones, Mara supports Schoen and Daboll, emphasizing the need for stability after years of resets.
Daboll, who has taken on a larger role with the quarterbacks this season, is expected to develop a new quarterback for 2025.
The Giants’ ownership, led by Mara and Steve Tisch, seems inclined to avoid another rebuild. They plan to stick with the current leadership for at least another year.
In Case You Didn’t Know
- Joe Schoen hails from Elkhart, Indiana, a background that laid the foundation for his deep connection to football and leadership.
- At DePauw University, Schoen showcased his versatility on the football field. He played as a quarterback during his freshman year before transitioning to wide receiver.
- Schoen graduated in 2001 with a degree in communications.
