Buffalo Bills QB Josh Allen and Los Angeles Chargers QB Justin Herbert’s silent rivalry heats up in 2025, with Allen entering as the reigning MVP, while Herbert faces pressure after playoff struggles and a fresh start under Jim Harbaugh.
Both QBs, Josh Allen and Justin Herbert, are trending across NFL circles right now due to the growing spotlight on two stars still seeking their first Super Bowl appearance.
Although they rarely speak about each other directly, their careers continue to be silently linked, and in 2025, both are entering seasons with high expectations and pressure.
Recently, Allen was featured in an interview with GQ, where he revealed his complete, grueling lifestyle transformation, along with that of his recently married wife, Hailee Steinfeld. In the interview, he states;
“Honestly, right now, it’s probably the best it’s ever been, partly because I wanted to look good for some recent events in my life… I was making sure that I was staying fit and slim so I could fit in the clothes. I just got an infrared sauna, and it’s got some red light as well. Me and my wife have been doing that almost daily… Working out, getting the right sleep, and a good diet—it’s been keeping me on a really good track.”
With this new transformation, fans believe Allen is fully locked in on a Super Bowl run—adding even more pressure on him to meet those sky-high expectations finally.
Additionally, he recently took on a creative off-field role as “Director of Billustration” for New Era Cap, blending football fame with personal branding.
On the other hand, Herbert is grabbing attention from training camp, not just for his performance, but also for wearing red-tinted contact lenses, which reportedly help with light sensitivity and focus.
Moreover, Justin Herbert is back under center with a clean slate, a new coaching staff led by Jim Harbaugh, and a system designed to finally bring postseason success to Los Angeles.
Despite his raw talent and physical gifts, Herbert was not included in Sports Illustrated’s 2025 “Top 50 NFL Players” list.
This sparked an online debate and highlighted the narrative that his career is still riding more on potential than results.
While other QBs like Patrick Mahomes, Joe Burrow, Lamar Jackson, Josh Allen, and Jalen Hurts seem to make it to the Top 50 list, only Herbert was left off.
Los Angeles Chargers QB Justin Herbert Feels the Pressure Under Jim Harbaugh’s High Hopes and Bold Expectations!
While Allen is under pressure to finally lead the Bills to a Super Bowl, Herbert faces even more scrutiny in 2025.
With a big contract, a new coach, and a strong roster, he’s out of excuses. If the Chargers fall short again, people may start asking again: “Is he overrated?”
It’s not the first time Justin Herbert’s skills have been questioned. Back in January 2025, after the Los Angeles Chargers’ shocking Wild Card loss to the Houston Texans, Herbert faced heavy criticism for failing to deliver.
On this, American sports analyst and former American football player Emmanuel Acho even said;
“I’ve never said Justin Herbert was bad, he’s not. I’ve only said that he was overrated and over praised. Both of which have never been more obviously true,”
With fans still harboring doubts about Herbert, he is under more pressure in 2025 as he needs to prove he can win meaningful games, not just put up big numbers.
Allen may carry expectations, but Herbert carries doubt.
In Case You Don’t Know
- Allen’s family owns a 3,000-acre cantaloupe and cotton farm in Firebaugh, California. He spent summers driving tractors and working the fields.
- Herbert graduated from Oregon with a degree in biology and once thought about becoming a doctor or surgeon.
- Not just an elite athlete, Herbert was also academically good; he was valedictorian of his high school class.
