A Former Bristol NFL Player, a Strip Club Argument, and a Piece of Blue Gum: How Aaron Hernandez Got Caught for Murder

Aaron was not selected until the fourth round of the 2010 NFL draft!

This article was last updated by on

Late New England Patriots tight end Aaron Hernandez, who died in a prison cell, was arrested in 2013 for the murder of his friend Odin Lloyd.

On June 17, 2013, Odin Lloyd was found dead in an industrial park near Aaron Hernandez’s home in North Attleborough, Massachusetts.

After analyzing surveillance footage, phone records, and physical evidence, police arrested Hernandez on June 26, 2013, for Lloyd’s murder.

At the time, Aaron Hernandez was a tight end for the New England Patriots, renowned for his talent and burgeoning NFL career.

Late NFL Tight End Aaron Hernandez Was Sentenced to Life Without Parole for the Murder of Odin Lloyd!

After the arrest, Hernandez denied any involvement in the crime. However, as the investigation continued, more evidence began to surface.

Following police investigation reports, surveillance footage revealed that Hernandez was holding a gun shortly before and after the time of the murder.

Additionally, cellphone records also proved that during the time of the murder, Aaron and Odin were tracked in the same location.

While this evidence was not enough on its own, later findings became the most compelling evidence, taking an interesting turn in the case.

According to police reports, a rental car was used during the crime scene, where they found blue bubble gum, which became the most significant evidence after the investigation.

Inside the car, investigators found a chewed piece of blue bubble gum, specifically Blue Cotton Candy Bubblicious, stuck to a spent shell casing.

Earlier that night, Hernandez had been seen on gas station footage buying that exact gum. ‘

DNA tests confirmed Hernandez had chewed the gum, and the shell casing matched the bullets used in Lloyd’s murder.

Later, after all the evidence, Aron was arrested for first-degree murder, which also later rebated the intention of murder.

According to investigative reports, Aaron Hernandez and Odin Lloyd were seen together at a Boston strip club, days before Lloyd was killed.

During that outing, Lloyd allegedly spoke to other patrons about Hernandez’s connection to a 2012 double homicide that was still under investigation at the time.

After the incident, Hernandez reportedly became angry and stormed out of the club.

Prosecutors later speculated that Hernandez may have feared Lloyd would talk to police or testify against him, especially if Lloyd knew about Hernandez’s past crimes.

This incident is widely believed to have triggered Hernandez’s decision to kill Lloyd, although no official motive was ever confirmed in court.

In Case You Don’t Know

  • While serving his life sentence without the possibility of parole, Aaron Hernandez was found dead by suicide in his prison cell on April 19, 2017.
Nishan
Nishan
Nishan Dahal writes sports with a human touch, covering breaking news, athlete lives, and the stories that stats can't tell. Nishan believes every athlete has a story worth telling. With the goal of bringing those stories to life with honesty, heart, and a touch of curiosity, he shares his insights through PlayerBio.

Related articles

Comments

Share article

Wayne L. Hartman, 78, Remembered as Canisteo Teacher, Athletic Director and Accomplished Wrestling Coach

CANISTEO, NY — Wayne L. Hartman, a longtime Canisteo educator, athletic director and respected coach whose career left a lasting mark on local students...

Former USF Athletic Director Doug Woolard Dies, Leaving Lasting Legacy at South Florida

The University of South Florida athletics community is mourning the passing of former Athletic Director Doug Woolard, whose leadership helped shape the university's athletic...

Greensboro, NC: Fight Breaks Out Between North Carolina A&T and Elon Players After Homecoming Game

A brief fight broke out between players from North Carolina A&T University and Elon University following their homecoming football game in Greensboro, North Carolina,...

Dale Brown Celebration of Life Set for November 11 at LSU’s Maravich Center

Former LSU basketball coach Dale Brown will be honored at a public Celebration of Life on November 11, following his passing on October 23...

Birmingham, Alabama: Terry Lee Ballew Dies at 74, Leaving Behind a Loving Family

Terry Lee Ballew, a devoted husband, father, grandfather, and longtime outdoorsman, passed away on October 22, 2026, at the age of 74. His death...