Jeff Garcia’s Wife: Carmella DeCesare Legal Issues & Early Life

This article was last updated by on

Carmella DeCesare is well-known for being the wife of Jeff Garcia, a former American football quarterback. She is a famous model and came into the limelight for her time in WWE as a WWE Diva Search contestant.

DeCesare was also Miss April 2003 for Playboy magazine and was named Playmate of the Year in 2004. She became famous because of her work as a model.

In 2008, Carmella was featured in the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issue in the player’s wives feature.


Carmella Decesare
Carmella Decesare Posing In A Swimwear (Source: Greedykidzgallery)

As of 2024, Jeff Garcia’s wife Carmella has a net worth of $2 million.

For more intriguing details on the former WWE diva please stick till the end of the article and do not forget to check out the facts table below.

Carmella DeCesare | Quick Facts

Full Name Carmella DeCesare 
Age 41 Years Old
Birth Date July 1, 1982
Birthplace Avon Lake, Ohio
Nationality American
Mother N/A
Father N/A
Married Yes
Star Sign Cancer
Height 5’8″ / 173 cm /1.73 m
Weight 54 kg / 119 lbs
Eye Color Brown
Hair Color Dark Brown
Husband Jeff Garcia
Children 4: Presley, Jason, Jax, Faith
High School Avon Lake High School
Education Business Administration
Profession Model, Professional Wrestler
Titles Playmate of the Year 2004
Net Worth $2 Million
Social Media Twitter
Jeff Garcia’s Merch  Football Trading Card, Autographed NFL Helmets
Last Update June, 2024

Carmella DeCesare | Early Life & Education

Carmella, originally Carmella Danielle DeCesare Garcia, was born on July 1, 1982, in Avon Lake, Ohio, United States. She was born to Puerto Rican and Italian parents.

She graduated from Avon Lake High School in 2000 and decided to pursue a degree in business administration at the university level. 

There is not much information about her and her parent’s background. But she grew up as a small-town girl and had a tough time in high school.

She was bullied by her high schoolmates and said she had only three close friends whom she trusted during hard times.

Carmella DeCesare | Modeling Career

DeCesare was watching TV, like any regular day, when she saw that the Fox reality show, “Who wants to be Playboy centerfold,” was looking for contestants.

She applied for it and even came to Los Angeles after the election, but the moment she arrived, Carmella had second thoughts about it.

Hugh Hefner, the publisher of Playboy, discovered her applications and saw her potential.

He personally invited her to the Playboy Mansion party to see if she wanted to reconsider her status as a member of the Playboy family.

Model Carmella Decesare
Carmella Decesare Modelling For A Photoshoot (Source:

Being unable to reject, Carmella joined the party and instantly loved the support.

However, she didn’t win the competition but was named a Playboy Cyber Girl of the Week, then a Cyber Girl of the Month, before being honored Playboy’s Miss April in 2003.

From a bullied small-town girl, Carmella became Playboy Royalty; she was enjoying her fame as a playmate.

DeCesare was photographed on the grounds of the Playboy Mansion in 2004 and was the first Playmates at Play calendar. She also modeled for the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issue in 2008.

Carmella DeCesare | TV Shows

Aside from her Playboy modeling work, Carmella has also appeared in several reality TV shows.

She appeared as a guest judge in The Girls Next Door (2005-2007), a reality show about Hugh Hefner’s girlfriends, and Playboy Shootout (2010)The Girls Next Door (2005-2007), a reality show about Hugh Hefner’s girlfriends, and Playboy Shootout (2010) as a guest judge.

She was also featured in The Real Housewives of San Diego (2010).

Also, Check Out Josh Allen’s Girlfriend: All About Brittany Morgan Williams >>

Carmella DeCesare | Height & Body Measurements

Carmella has several distinguishing characteristics that make her unique and beautiful. She stands at the height of 1.73 m and weighs about 154 lbs.

She had the biggest insecurities with her breast size. It was one of the reasons she backed out, thinking she wasn’t good enough.

Carmella Decesare
Carmella Decesare Profile ( Source:

But, she had the raw beauty qualities that made her shine in the modeling industry. More than the hourglass body, it was her beauty that stood out.

Her tanned, somewhat olive complexion, a fascinating mix of Italian and Puerto Rican ancestry, and natural beauty cannot be overlooked.

She became famous due to her natural beauty; however, she had breast implant surgery in 2005.

Carmella DeCesare | Professional Wrestling Career

Carmella made her WWE debut in 2004 as a contestant in the WWE Diva Search of that year.

The WWE Diva made it to the final four out of twenty-eight competitors, including future WWE talents Michele McCool and Maria Kanellis.

Decesare finished the competition as the runner-up. She was called to participate in “WWE Monday Night RAW” among numerous other competitors.

She had a feud with Christy Hemme, the winner of the Diva Search. This prompted the two to compete in a Lingerie Pillow Fight, in which Carmella lost.

It was aired in a TV special called “WWE Taboo Tuesday (2004).” However, she left the promotion soon after.

Carmella DeCesare And Jeff Garcia | Married Life 

In late March, Jeff Garcia opted to spend a night out with his new teammates in Cleveland. Instead, the Playboy Playmate of the Year, Carmella, stood across the room at a packed party.

He saw Carmella and was intimidated by her, his teammates told him that she was out of his league and to back off. Garcia knew he liked her and moved forward.

He made a move to talk to her and asked for her phone number, but she refused.

Carmella said she was pretty terrified by Jeff when he talked to her as he was 34, and she was just 21 then. She didn’t know that man was the one she was gonna marry.

But despite the rejection, Jeff asked her out again after being a successful football player. They dated for a long time before officially tying the knot on April 21, 2007.

The wedding was held at CordeValle Resort in San Martin, California.

Also, Check Out Paul Kariya: Mighty Ducks, Jersey, NHL, Retire, Wife & Net Worth >>

Carmella DeCesare | Husband ‘Jeffrey Garcia.’

Carmella’s husband, Jeffrey Garcia, is a former American football quarterback. He was born on February 24, 1970.

After completing high school and junior college in Gilroy, California, Garcia played for San Jose State University.

Jeff began his professional football career as an undrafted free agent with the Calgary Stampeders of the Canadian Football League (CFL) in 1994.

Likewise, he was a four-time CFL All-Star and four-time NFL Pro Bowl pick. Jeff debuted with the San Francisco 49ers in the National Football League (NFL) in 1999.

In 2010, he became a member of the United Football League’s Omaha Nighthawks. He signed with the Houston Texans in 2011 but did not appear in a game for the organization.

In 2012, Jeff Garcia retired at the age of 41. He has been honored with the NFL Hall of Fame for three years and still owns the single-season throwing yards record for the 49ers.

As of 2022, Jeff is involved in many charity work and also works as a coach for Torrey Pines Pop Warner Football.

Carmella DeCesare | Children

Carmella has four children: two sons and two daughters. The couple had their first children after a year after their marriage.

It was a baby girl who was born on April 28, 2008. The couple named her Presley.

Carmella's Children
Carmella’s and Jeff’s Children (Source: Instagram)

After a year, Carmella got pregnant with her second child and gave birth in June 2009. It was their first son, and they named him Jason.

On September 21, 2010, Carmella gave birth to another baby boy and named him Jax. Finally, in December 2011, their fourth baby, Faith, was born. 

Carmella DeCesare’s | Legal Issues

Carmella was sentenced to 24 hours of community service, one year of probation, and a $150 fine for karate kicking a lady named Kristen Hine in a bar on August 21, 2004.

DeCesare pled not guilty to assault in a Cleveland, Ohio, court on September 10, 2004. On January 12, 2005, she was acquitted of assault but found guilty of breaking a restraining order.

Similarly, DeCesare testified that her boyfriend, Jeff Garcia, had cheated on her with his ex-girlfriend Kristen Hine during the trial.

Carmella DeCesare | Net worth

Carmella DeCesare has an estimated net worth of $2 million. She earned that worth through her modeling career and appearing in a variety of shows.

At the same time, Carmella’s husband, Jeff Garcia, has a net worth of $25 million, and when combined, both have a net worth of around $27 million.

Carmella said that she wants people to acknowledge her as an individual rather than for being the wife of Jeff Garcia.

She says that she has been working hard to make a name, fame, and money for herself not to be overshadowed by others’ names.

Furthermore, she added she would love to be known as model Carmella than just Jeff Garcia’s wife.

Carmella DeCesare | Social Media

Carmella is not active on social media; thus, she doesn’t have a Facebook or Instagram account.

She does use Twitter, but she isn’t active there as, well. She has just 1399 followers on Twitter.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Jeff Garcia (@jeffgarciaqb5)

The above Instagram post is of Carmella’s husband, Jeff Garcia.

Popularity Graph 

Carmella is a popular model, a former WWE contestant, and a mother of four.

Carmella DeCesare
Carmella DeCesare Popularity Graph ( Source: Google)

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Did Carmella have breast implants?

Yes. DeCesare had breast implants in 2005, as she was insecure about her body.

Why did Carmella fight with Kristen Hine?

Apparently, Carmella fought with Kristen Hine as she was having an affair with her boyfriend, Jeff Garcia.

What is Carmella DeCesare doing currently?

Carmella is involved with her husband in the charity organization Garcia Pass It On Foundation, which shares resources for people in less fortunate circumstances.

Also, Read About Artemi Panarin’s Girlfriend, Alisa Znarok: Bio & Net Worth >> 

Shaddy is a passionate writer and overall wordsmith. She is committed to satisfying your appetite for the content. She is not only an avid celebrity style enthusiast but also a singer herself. She makes cover songs during her free times.

Related articles



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share article

Latest News